Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Promise and Purpose of Allen Island Stewardship

Allen Island has lived many lives. 

For thousands of years, Indigenous peoples hunted, fished, and lived on the island in the summertime. In the early 17th century, it was the first stop that British explorer George Weymouth made on his expedition to Maine. He returned to England with Indigenous captives, two from the island community. Indigenous presence on the island persisted even after European contact, but they were eventually forced off of the land. 

It was used by fishermen as a temporary base throughout the 17th and 18th centuries, until a Gloucester fisherman named John Allen laid claim to it. He established a permanent residence, a family, and a flock of sheep. Other families followed suit, and the island eventually harbored 11 families and a small school. After motorized fishing boats replaced the oar and sail, island fishing communities began to decline. Allen Island was largely abandoned, used for storing fishing gear and the occasional logging operation. 

Then, it was purchased by Betsy Wyeth, an author and art collector, who was also the business manager for her husband, renowned painter Andrew Wyeth. For the next forty years, Betsy Wyeth reshaped the island to fit her vision and inspire her husband’s work. One end of the forested island was cleared to create grazing pasture for sheep. A wharf was built to support local lobstermen. Old structures were removed or restored, new structures were added, and the island was landscaped with ponds, sculptures, paths, and plantings. 

In 2022, the College took ownership of the island after five years of partnering with Betsy Wyeth’s Up East Foundation to run programs and do research there. In addition to carrying on the Wyeth legacy, the College has incorporated the island into various aspects of its programming. Allen Island is advertised by the College as The Island Campus.

Campus groups and teams have used the island for bonding retreats, an assortment of faculty do research on topics ranging from oceanography to ornithology on the island, and students can apply to participate in the Island Campus Summer Research Fellowship. Lachlan Bailey `27, who was an Island Fellow in 2025 and returned as Head Fellow in 2026, spent his first summer conducting a feasibility study for a hydroelectric generator to power the island. 

Part of the job of an Island Fellow is to join the permanent crew of five in maintaining Allen Island’s landscape and infrastructure, and to help out when the island receives visitors. Describing the range of people he encountered, Bailey said, “Some people are there to take pictures, some people are there to write about it for the College, some people are there just to hang out, some people are there… to take tree core samples or, you know, measure the salinity of the water.”  

Among the media coverage and press releases surrounding the College’s ownership of the island, “stewardship” is the term that consistently arises, and a statement by President David Greene says that the College “will carry Betsy Wyeth’s vision forward through our commitment to the community, to the islands being centers of discovery, and to conserving a natural environment that is truly inspirational.” As the College adjusts to having the island as a resource and a responsibility, it will have to decide how best to “carry Betsy Wyeth’s vision forward” and what it means to be a thoughtful steward. 

According to Whitney King, the College’s Dr. Frank and Theodora Miselis professor of chemistry, “Colby College owns Allen and Benner Island, but the deed has restrictions…we can’t build more than 20 percent onto any building, we can’t go put a golf course on the island, we can’t put a wind turbine on the island.” 

King, who has been very involved in the relationship between Allen Island and the College from the beginning, emphasizes the College’s role as “stewards of [Betsy Wyeth’s] legacy.” Though the “hard and fast legal restrictions” on what the College can and cannot do on the island only last about five more years, he believes the College’s prerogative should be to preserve what Wyeth created. “So, could we paint the buildings pink? Probably. We’d probably have to wait five years. Is that a good idea? No.” 

Bailey also expressed that no outlandish changes would be made: “they’re not gonna, you know, bulldoze the forest and put a new West Lot there.” For Bailey, stewardship of the island involves “aesthetic preservation” as well as commitment to maintaining existing partnerships with local lobstermen and respect for the artifacts that are products of its long and winding history, from Native American tools to Andrew Wyeth’s art. 

Many of the ideas around stewardship revolve around preservation. One does wonder, however, what changes will be made. One area of interest is the ecology of the island. Greene references “conserving a natural environment” in his statement, but from an ecological perspective, the Allen Island that is beloved today is not exactly “natural.” It is an environment that has been influenced in varying degrees by human activity for centuries, from Indigenous hunting and fishing to Betsy Wyeth’s sheep grazing and artificial ponds. 

According to Justin Becknell, associate professor and chair of environmental studies, this changes, for better or worse, the way ecological research can be conducted on the island. He says, “If you want to go there and study the forests, the first question you ask is, well, what have people been doing to this forest?” Restoration of a “natural” environment on the island could entail anything from re-introducing animal populations that previously existed on the island to allowing cleared areas to become forested again by simply leaving them be. 

Whether the “deep respect for the land” Greene references in his statement will translate to a desire to do ecological restoration work is just one of many questions that arise in thinking about what stewardship of the island means. Allen Island has lived many lives; the College will determine what course this next one takes.  

 

 

~ Anna Izquierdo `29

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply