Press "Enter" to skip to content

Toxic Chemicals and the Limits of Consumer Protection in Maine

Markers, finger paints, modelling clay and stuffed toys are by no means the products you’d normally think of as containing hazardous chemicals. They’ve become almost inextricably linked with childhood. Yet a lot of recent work happening in Maine has cast a serious light on what these products contain and how little the average consumer may actually know about the chemicals their kids are exposed to daily.

On Oct. 23, the Portland Press Herald reported that a number of major manufacturers (including Crayola and Build-A-Bear Workshop) had failed to disclose hazardous chemicals in children’s products sold in Maine even though they had reported those same chemicals to regulators in other states. The story was part of an investigation by Defend Our Health, a Portland-based non-profit that examined chemical disclosures submitted in Vermont, Washington, and Oregon.

Crayola had reported formaldehyde in over 300 children’s products (including washable markers, finger paints, and modelling clay). Build-A-Bear had reported phthalates, arsenic, and mercury in some of their toy accessories. Neither company had submitted those reports to the Maine regulators as per the investigation and the Maine Department of Environmental Protection.

These findings are of considerable concern in light of the health hazards posed by the chemicals in question. Formaldehyde is a known human carcinogen, and phthalates have been shown to be endocrine disruptors. Mercury and lead are heavy metals that are known to have adverse effects on neurological development, particularly in young children.

However, the presence of a hazardous chemical doesn’t necessarily mean that a product is an immediate danger. You have to look at the level and duration of exposure in order to assess the health risk. Crayola has denied the allegations, saying their products are safe and that formaldehyde is not added intentionally but is a by-product of the preservatives.

Still, the dispute raises the wider question of how effective environmental regulation is. If the same chemical can be in a different category depending on how a state defines an intentionally added ingredient, then what level of protection can consumers reasonably expect from our regulations?

Maine’s Kid Safe Products Act of 2008 was specifically designed to deal with that issue. It requires manufacturers to report certain hazardous chemicals used in products for children, enabling the state to identify the potential for risk and then consider appropriate restrictions.

There’s a major caveat in the law, though. Simply reporting a hazardous chemical doesn’t in itself stop a company from selling the product. The system is entirely dependent on the manufacturer reporting their own use of the chemical, and the regulator is entirely reliant on the accuracy of that reporting.

It wasn’t routine state oversight that first brought the reporting discrepancies to light; it was an independent non-profit looking at the records of other states.

There’s also a wider environmental justice issue. Children are particularly susceptible to certain chemical exposures as their bodies and nervous systems are still developing. They have far less control over the products they’re exposed to than adults do (at home, at school, at day care, etc.).

The responsibility of avoiding hazardous chemicals is often placed on the parent or the teacher to interpret the labels, do the research, and find the safer alternative. That presumes the consumer has the information to make the right choice and has the time and money to act on it.

For low-income families, the prospect of replacing household goods or buying more expensive alternatives is simply not realistic. The same applies to public schools and childcare provision, which all operate within very tight budgets.

As a result, inadequate chemical regulation may go well beyond individual consumer choices and actually reinforce the very inequalities in environmental health that we’re already seeing. A child’s exposure to hazardous chemicals shouldn’t depend on their family’s ability to research product ingredients or their ability to afford a different product.

A lot of these products aren’t accepted by the local hazardous waste facilities, so the consumer is left with very limited options other than putting them in normal household rubbish. Depending on how the waste is disposed of, the chemical-containing products could end up in landfills or incinerators, which raises further issues around pollution and waste.

This is the perennial problem with environmental policy. We tend to look at individual bits of the life cycle of a product (the manufacturing, consumption, and disposal) and not take into account the links between them. A chemical which is of concern during consumer use doesn’t just vanish when the product is disposed of.

This is really about corporate responsibility more than it is about the safety of children’s toys. The companies decide what goes into their products, and then the consumers and the local authorities are left to deal with the fallout.

One possible route would be to place more responsibility on the manufacturers right through the product life cycle (clearer chemical disclosures, safer product design, schemes to collect potentially hazardous materials after use, etc.). That would reduce the burden on the consumer and would also get the manufacturers to think about the environmental and public health implications of their products before they even get to the shop.

Ultimately, this controversy isn’t just about whether or not the companies reported properly. It’s about the fundamental flaws in a system that places a huge amount of trust in the information that companies provide, and yet expects the consumer to make an informed decision with only a partial picture.

Kids shouldn’t have to rely on the investigative work of non-profits to find out whether the products they use every day contain potentially hazardous chemicals. Parents shouldn’t have to wade through a maze of chemical regulations just to buy a basic school supply. The responsibility should fall on manufacturers and regulators to ensure that products associated with childhood are not quietly putting children’s health at risk.

 

 

 

~ Jane Kulevich `29

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply